Was Leonardo da Vinci homosexual? Sources, trial and relationship with Salaigh

Two profiles drawn by Leonardo da Vinci, an old man and a young man
Biographical survey · archives · workshop

A Florentine accusation in 1476, a life without a known wife, male companions and nearly thirty years of proximity to Salaikh: the clues are real. But their meaning requires more precision than legend.

Short answer

Leonardo's attraction to men is plausible, but it cannot be proven as an identity in the modern sense. The 1476 case is documented without conviction. Salaikh was certainly his student, assistant and long-term relative; no preserved document explicitly names him as her lover.

Drawn profile of a young man with curly hair, associated with Leonardo da Vinci's entourage
Profile of young man associated with Leonardo's entourage. The drawings of young men with curly hair do not constitute identified portraits of Salaikh.
What can be said

A legitimate question, an answer without false certainty

The word "homosexual" today designates an orientation or identity. In 15th century Florence, archives mainly speak of forbidden acts, reputation and urban discipline: they do not classify people with our categories.

It is therefore necessary to separate three levels. The first is documentary: in 1476, Leonardo is aptly named in a denunciation for sodomy. The second is biographical: we know of neither marriage nor attested female affair - an absence which proves nothing in itself - and he shared his work lastingly with men, notably Salaigh then Francesco Melzi. The third is interpretative: artists, historians and psychoanalysts have sought confirmation in the works that they cannot provide alone.

The fairest wording is neither "we know nothing" nor "Salaikh was certainly her lover". It is more nuanced: the sources make an attraction to men credible, but they do not directly document either a claimed identity or the sexual nature of a specific relationship.

01

Documented

A Florentine procedure from 1476, the absence of known marriage, the lasting presence of Salaigh and Melzi, and the provisions of the will.

02

Plausible

Leonardo's attraction to men, emotional intimacy with certain companions, and the influence of young models on his ideal of beauty.

03

Not demonstrated

Whether Salaikh was her lover, whether each young face was her portrait, or whether the paintings make it possible to diagnose a sexual orientation.

Current view of Palazzo Vecchio in Florence, seat of the city government
The Palazzo Vecchio recalls the civic framework of Republican Florence. The documents in the case are now kept at the Archivio di Stato.
Florence · 1476

The trial which was not a conviction

In the spring of 1476, an anonymous post accused several young men of having had sexual relations with Jacopo Saltarelli, an apprentice goldsmith aged around seventeen. Leonardo, then aged twenty-four and still linked to Verrocchio's workshop, was among those denounced.

The procedure falls under the Ufficiali di Notte, the "Officers of the Night", a magistracy created to monitor and prosecute sodomy. The accusation was serious. The procedure, however, ends without a known conviction. The documents kept therefore establish a denunciation and an investigation, not a guilty verdict.

april 9

First anonymous denunciation. Leonard and three other men are named with Jacopo Saltarelli.

june 7

The denunciation is repeated. The preserved documents still do not result in any known convictions.

Issue

Prosecutions are dismissed or dropped. There is no judgment finding Leonardo guilty.

Important clarification: to say that Leonardo was "convicted of homosexuality" is false. To say that the accusation never existed is just as false. The archives establish a denunciation and a procedure without conviction.

Social context

In Florence, sodomy was a legal act, not an identity

Renaissance Florence had a masculine culture very structured by workshops, brotherhoods, clienteles and age gaps. Relations between men could be part of these sociability, but they were also monitored, punished and used in political or personal rivalries.

Historian Michael Rocke has shown, from court records, that prosecutions were numerous and that practices were more diffuse than the image of a handful of "homosexuals" separated from the rest of society. Modern categories therefore do not overlap properly with 15th century archives.

This prudence should not erase the possibility of desire. It only avoids transforming a judicial word, "sodomy", into a complete diagnosis of the intimate identity of a man of whom no personal diary has been preserved.

Gian Giacomo Caprotti · known as Salaikh

Student entered workshop at ten years old

Gian Giacomo Caprotti da Oreno, nicknamed Salaikh or Salai, joined Leonardo's house-workshop in Milan in 1490, around the age of ten. A note from Leonardo immediately describes a difficult, greedy, lying, thief and stubborn child. The nickname refers to the "little devil" of a popular story.

These criticisms do not end their relationship. Salaikh remained linked to Leonardo for almost three decades, as a student, assistant, trusted man and painter in his own right. He traveled with the workshop, wore expensive clothes paid for or counted by Leonardo, and finally received a share of Milanese vines in the will of 1519.

This duration is remarkable. It establishes a deep human and professional proximity. However, she does not say, on her own, whether it was paternal, emotional, economic, sexual - or several of these dimensions at different times.

1480 approx.

Birth of Gian Giacomo Caprotti near Milan.

1490

Entrance into Leonardo's workshop, still a child.

1505 -1515

Assistant and painter activity in the studio orbit.

1519

Leonardo's will leaves him half of the Milanese vines.

1524

Death of Salaigh in Milan. This death after that of Leonardo does not shed light on the nature of their relationship.

What is missing

No preserved letters qualify him as a lover or describe a sexual relationship.

Weigh the clues

The relationship with Salaì: proof, possibility and invention

A more honest picture is obtained by not asking every detail to "prove" the same thing. Some facts are solid, others support a hypothesis, still others are a late reconstruction.

Established facts

Sustainable proximity

  • Salaikh entered the workshop in 1490.
  • Leonardo's accounts and notes record his behavior, expenses and clothing.
  • He remained associated with the workshop for decades.
  • He receives half of the Milan vineyard in the will.
  • He developed his own activity as a painter based on Leonardo models.
Plausible interpretations

Affection, desire, model

  • Leonardo's tolerance towards Salaikh can reflect an exceptional personal attachment.
  • The curly beauty of some young men corresponds to the type associated with those around him.
  • An intimate or sexual relationship is possible in the context of biographical cues.
  • Certain tables were able to use Salaikh as a model, without all the cases being documented.
Which the sources do not prove

An identifiable "couple"

  • No contract, poem, confession or direct testimony names Salaikh as a lover.
  • Material inheritance is not a statement of sexual orientation.
  • An androgynous face is not automatically a portrait of Salaikh.
  • The procedure of 1476, fourteen years before his arrival, does not document anything about their relationship.
Images, models, projections

Works can suggest an ideal, not reveal a private life

Young faces with abundant curls, ambiguous smiles and supple bodies nourished Leonardo's queer readings. They are fruitful for the history of reception. But the identification of models often remains uncertain, and iconography is not an intimate document.

Salaigh and Melzi

Two close ones, two different heritages

Francesco Melzi later joined Leonardo, accompanied him to France and watched over him in his later years. Opposing a Salaikh "lover" to a Melzi "secretary" is attractive, but too simple. The documents mainly distribute roles and goods.

Gian Giacomo Caprotti

Salaì, long irregular loyalty

Present since childhood, alternately a source of annoyance, assistant, painter and beneficiary of the will.

Entrance
1490, in Milan
Duration
Nearly thirty years of documented connection with the workshop
Legacy
Half of the Milanese vines
Relationship
Exceptional proximity; undocumented sexuality
Francesco Melzi

Melzi, the intellectual heir

Young Lombard nobleman, cultured disciple, traveling companion and guardian of the handwritten corpus.

Entrance
Around 1506 -1508
Last years
Rome then Amboise, with Leonardo
Legacy
Books, instruments, drawings and manuscripts
Relationship
Attested friendship and trust; undocumented sexuality

The will does not resolve a sentimental rivalry. He entrusted Melzi with Leonardo's intellectual memory and gave Salaikh significant land. These legacies prove the place of the two men, not the exact form of their intimacy.

The silence of sources does not prohibit the hypothesis. It only prohibits presenting the hypothesis as an archive.
Freud and modern readings

Why did the legend grow so much?

In 1910, Sigmund Freud published a study on a childhood memory of Leonardo. He constructs an interpretation of his sexuality, his mother and his desire sublimated in research. The text has had a lasting impact on popular culture, but it is partly based on an erroneous translation: the nibbio from the Italian text is a kite, not a vulture.

Since then, novels, films and essays have sometimes treated Salaì as a universal key. Queer studies have also helped reopen the subject, reveal what older biographies left unsaid and question the masculine ideal in the works. Their value does not depend on the impossible discovery of a modern certificate of sexual orientation.

Good history therefore distinguishes contemporary visibility from historical evidence. We can recognize the strong plausibility of a masculine desire in Leonardo without inventing intimate scenes that the documents do not tell.

Reading method

Six questions so as not to turn a biography into a rumor

Is the source contemporary?

The legal file of 1476 weighs more than a fictionalized story of the 20th century.

Does it describe an act or an identity?

Florentine justice pursues acts qualified as sodomy; it does not define a modern orientation.

Is there a conviction?

No. The existence of a charge does not amount to a guilty verdict.

Is a model identified?

For the Saint John the Baptist, identification with Salaikh remains debated.

Does the will speak of love?

No. It distributes property among relatives and documents their importance.

What does "probable" mean?

A reasonable conclusion from converging clues, different from an explicitly attested fact.

Extend your gaze

The Saint John and Bacchus of the workshop

These two figures are among the most discussed images when we approach desire, androgyny and the circulation of models in Leonardo. The shop's reproductions above all allow us to study light, gesture, sfumato and the ambiguity of the gaze on the scale of the painting.

Also read

The workshop sheds light on the daily lives of Salaikh and Melzi better than isolated speculations.

Salaigh, Melzi and the workshop
Frequently asked questions

FAQs

Can we say that Leonardo da Vinci was homosexual?

The word today designates an orientation or identity that 15th century sources do not formulate. An attraction to men seems plausible, but no document allows Leonardo to be attributed a modern identity with certainty.

Was Leonardo da Vinci convicted of sodomy?

No. Leonardo was named in an anonymous denunciation in 1476. The proceedings ended without a known conviction: a documented accusation is not a guilty verdict.

Who was Jacopo Saltarelli?

Jacopo Saltarelli was a young Florentine apprentice goldsmith, aged around seventeen, named in the denunciation of 1476. Modern accounts sometimes add spectacular qualifications to him that sources do not always justify.

Who was Salaikh for Leonardo da Vinci?

Gian Giacomo Caprotti, known as Salaikh, entered Leonardo's house-workshop around ten years old in 1490. He remained his student, assistant, painter and relative for almost three decades, and received half of the Milanese vines by will.

Was Salaikh Leonardo's lover?

This is a possible hypothesis, but not proven. No preserved document explicitly describes a sexual or romantic relationship between Leonardo and Salaikh.

Did Salaikh pose for Saint John the Baptist?

This identification is traditional and still taken up by certain institutions. The Biblioteca Ambrosiana takes up this identification, but the Louvre notice does not name a model. It therefore does not allow us to conclude with certainty.

Why are we also talking about Francesco Melzi?

Francesco Melzi accompanied Leonardo during his last years, treated him in his last illness and inherited his books, drawings and manuscripts. His place shows that Leonardo's close entourage is not reduced to Salaikh.

Which historical conclusion is more conservative?

The sources make Leonardo's attraction to men credible, but they do not directly document either a claimed identity or the sexual nature of a specific relationship. We must distinguish between facts, hypotheses and modern receptions.

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.