Gustav Klimt · landscape · around 1904 -1905
Rose bushes under the trees: filtered light and plant mosaic
In this almost skyless square, three rose bushes slip under three apple trees. Klimt does not describe a garden plant by plant: he transforms leaves, flowers and light into a vibrant surface where space seems to breathe in small touches of color.
Direct response
Why does this garden seem lit from the inside?
Because Klimt avoids the bright frontal sun and deep shadows. The light passes through the crowns of the apple trees, fragments in the foliage then reappears in the form of small yellow, light green, pink and white notes. It does not illuminate objects from the outside: it seems to circulate between the keys.
The painter also reduces the depth. The short trunks give some reference points, but the plant masses fit together like pieces of a tapestry. The three rose bushes in the foreground are not placed in front of a decoration: they belong to the same colorful network as the three large crowns of trees.
Three rose bushes
Their low flowering enlivens the lower edge and introduces pink and white accents.
Three apple trees
Their oval crowns close the space and constitute the main architecture.
A tiny sky
The small opening at the top right is enough to locate the garden without breaking its immersion.
Architecture of the gaze
A square with no vanishing point
The square format refuses any dominant direction. Neither horizontal panorama nor vertical elevation: the image unfolds in all directions with almost architectural stability. The viewer does not enter through an alley; he immediately finds himself facing a living wall.
However, the composition remains very constructed. The three tree crowns occupy the upper half; their narrow trunks descend towards the rose bushes. On the right, a small triangle of sky and a distant hill create breathing space. Without this escape, the surface would become completely decorative.
A higher mass
The trees form a continuous canopy, but their crowns remain legible like three nested volumes.
A low floral stripe
The rose bushes lighten the foreground and interrupt the monotony of the green with finer rhythms.
Compressed depth
Overlays indicate space, while the uniform key brings each plane closer to the surface.
Filtered light
The sun becomes colored dust
Klimt paints neither spectacular rays nor black shadows. It makes light felt by differences in temperature and value: a more yellow green, a paler pink, a suddenly colder blue-green.
The foliage acts as a filter. Each touch receives a different amount of light, so that green ceases to be a unique color. It becomes a family: olive, emerald, sage, blue-green, acidic yellow and silver gray.
Roses play a decisive role. They first attract the eye by contrast, then force it to return to the foliage where similar hues are hidden. This repeated movement - flower, leaf, flower - transforms reading into a journey rather than immediate identification.
This method owes more to impressionism and post-impressionism than to academic naturalism. But Klimt does not follow a scientific division of color. Its small marks vary freely, sometimes becoming commas, sometimes scales or punctuations.
Palette observed
A plant mosaic, not a uniform green
From a distance, the painting seems dominated by green. Up close, its stability is based on a multitude of variations which move the leaves forward or backward without resorting to traditional modeling.
Three useful comparisons
From the breathable garden to the almost abstract carpet
These landscapes show that Klimt does not repeat a formula: he shifts the balance between depth, plant structure and decorative intensity.
Poppy field
The flowery ground almost becomes a pointillist sheet. The reds disperse more regularly and the eye has less vertical support.
Country garden with sunflowers
The flowers rise to the upper edge. The hierarchy between background and foreground dissolves more than in Rose bushes under the trees.
Litzlberg on the Attersee
The square remains, but the water establishes a wide horizontality. Klimt adapts his decorative vocabulary to a more open view.
The landscape experienced
Litzlberg and the Attersee: a summer laboratory
Between 1904 and 1907, Klimt spent his summers in Litzlberg, on the Attersee. The surrounding area offers orchards, flowery meadows, bodies of water and isolated architecture: so many motifs that he frames with almost photographic concentration.
Rest is not the absence of work. Klimt observes, frames and simplifies. Attersee's landscapes allow him to move questions already present in his portraits to nature: how to fit a profusion of motifs into a unified surface? How to contrast a clear structure with abundant visual material?
The sketch associated with Rose bushes under the trees found in Sonja Knips' red notebook, used between 1897 and 1905. He confirms that the painting is the result of a constructed elaboration, even if the final touch seems spontaneous.
Property history
From Victor Zuckerkandl to the restitution to the heirs of Nora Stiasny
The beauty of the garden should not mask its history in the 20th century. The painting is also an important case of research into provenance and repair of Nazi dispossession.
Victor Zuckerkandl purchased the work, then known as Apple tree.
After the Anschluss, Nora Stiasny is forced to sell it well below its value in an attempt to escape.
France acquired the painting for the Musée d'Orsay, without its entire ownership history being established.
After further research, the work was returned to the heirs of Nora Stiasny. Today it belongs to a private collection.
Nora Stiasny, niece of Victor and Paula Zuckerkandl, received the work as part of the family estate. In 1942, she was murdered with her mother, husband and son. The restitution announced by the Musée d'Orsay in March 2021 results from cross-research carried out in France and Austria.
The investigation also corrected previous confusion with Apple tree II, returned by Austria in 2001 to the Stiasny heirs before research in 2017 concluded that it was probably not the work owned by Nora. This file shows how old titles, photographs, sales and family archives must be compared with caution.
Continue the garden
Reproductions and landscapes by Klimt to combine
For a coherent decoration, choose a set of square formats and let the greens interact. The images below are all different from those already shown in the article.
Reference sources
To verify the work and its provenance
Frequently asked questions
Rose bushes under the trees in eight answers
When did Klimt paint Rose bushes under the trees ?
The work is generally dated around 1904 -1905. The sketch kept in Sonja Knips' red notebook, used until 1905, supports this dating.
What are the dimensions of the table?
The canvas measures 110 × 110 cm. This square format contributes to balance without dominant direction and brings the landscape closer to a tapestry.
What trees are represented?
Reference sources identify three apple trees in the background, in front of which three small rose bushes are displayed.
Is the table pointillist?
He shows an influence of pointillism and post-impressionism, but Klimt does not apply a strict scientific method. Its keys remain free, irregular and adapted to each element.
Is the painting still in the Musée d'Orsay?
No. The work, long kept at the Musée d'Orsay, was returned to the heirs of Nora Stiasny in 2021 -2022. It is now in a private collection.
Why do we see so little sky?
Klimt wants to produce a feeling of immersion under the trees. The small opening at the top right is enough to give a horizon while maintaining the density of the canopy.
Where was the landscape probably studied?
The painting is associated with Klimt's summers in Litzlberg, on the Attersee, where he painted meadows and gardens near the Bräuhof. The exact location of the motif, however, should not be stated without proof.
How to choose a reproduction?
Keep the square format to respect the composition. In a light room, a natural wood frame, dark brown or deep green, lets the roses play their accent role without competing with the painting.
Bring Klimt filtered light into your interior
Discover the reproduction of Rose bushes under the trees, then compare the artist's other orchards and square gardens to compose a coherent whole.
0 comments