Van Gogh and Rembrandt: admiration, copies and influence
Van Gogh is not looking to become a new Rembrandt. However, he recognizes it in the 17th century mastere century a freedom of touch, a moral light and a human tenderness capable of helping the painting modern.
How did Rembrandt influence Van Gogh?
By three complementary routes. First, direct observation: at the Rijksmuseum, Van Gogh studies The Jewish Bride and The Trustees, particularly the hands, the looks and the passages left free. Then, the reproductions: engravings and heliogravures allow him to live with the old masters far from the museums. Finally, an idea of the painting : Rembrandt proves to him that we can unite visible matter, chiaroscuro, truth of faces and spiritual emotion.
This influence never suppresses others. Millet structures his peasant imagination; Delacroix teaches him color; the impressionists lighten his palette; Japanese prints modify his framing. Rembrandt remains less a model of style to repeat than an inner authority: a painter who gives human presence a universal scope.
From written admiration to painted transposition
The tutelary name
In his first letters, Vincent already cites Rembrandt among the artists who give depth to biblical life and stories.
The designer
He observes popular figures, old men and readers, often through reproductions.
The Amsterdam Shock
At the newly opened Rijksmuseum, The Jewish Bride, The Trustees and Hals renews his thoughts on the sidelines.
The tenderness of the looks
From Saint-Rémy, he writes that Rembrandt almost alone possesses a moving tenderness and a feeling of infinity.
Lazarus in color
It transforms a detail of Rembrandt's etching into a small one painting solar.
The Jewish Bride: the painting which Van Gogh wanted to stay in front of
After saving for the trip, Van Gogh goes to the Rijksmuseum with his friend Anton Kerssemakers. His admiration for The Jewish Bride became legendary: Kerssemakers reported in 1912 that he would have happily sacrificed ten years of his life to stay two weeks in front of the painting with only dry bread. The testimony is late; it must therefore be presented as a reported memory, not as a sentence written in Vincent's handwriting.
Contemporary letters are more certain. Van Gogh describes the work as intimate and infinitely sympathetic. What stops him is not just the story of Isaac and Rebecca, but the passage between hands and clothes: the flesh is carefully, the gold and red are placed thickly, certain details are scraped into the dough. For him, Rembrandt then ceases to be only "true from nature": he becomes a poet, that is to say a creator.
The lesson is not to paint brown. It consists of choosing where to finish and where to let the surface breathe. The strongest material focuses on what carries the feeling: contact of the hands, weight of the fabrics, silence of the faces.
Trustees and the freedom of the "first move"
In a letter dated October 13, 1885, Van Gogh insisted on the hands of Rembrandt and Frans Hals: they live without being finished according to academic conventions. He also admires heads whose eyes, nose and mouth seem to rest from the first brush strokes. This saving is crucial for an artist often accused of clumsiness.
The Trustees of the Draper Guild, painted in 1662, offers an ideal laboratory. The five leaders and their servant are not detailed equally. The light, white-collar workers, red carpet and direction of gaze are enough to produce a meeting by train to unfold. Van Gogh draws a practical rule from this: when a passage works, do not smooth it; when it fails, it is better to take it up frankly than to tire it out with retouching.
It will not take up the composition of the Trustees, but this hierarchy of finish reappears in his portraits: an eye or a mouth can be precise while the garment remains crossed by separate touches.
The Resurrection of Lazarus: from the black of the print to the Provençal sun
Van Gogh does not work in front of the original. He has a rotogravure published after the fifth state of Rembrandt's great etching. He takes the lower part: Lazarus and his two sisters. Christ, his gesture and the crowd disappear from the field. The tight framing transforms a theatrical scene into a group of three figures.
The essential mutation comes from color. The blacks in the print become green, yellow, blue and orange. The light no longer only descends into the cave: a solar disk rises above the landscape. To say that the sun "is "christ would be an interpretation, because Van Gogh does not explain it that way in the known letter. But the visual replacement is powerful: the source of the miracle is absent, while light invades the world.
Lazarus' face has sometimes been compared to that of Van Gogh. The resemblance seems plausible, especially by the red beard, but no document establishes a symbolic self-portrait. Caution allows us to better see what is certain: Vincent doesn't color Rembrandt; he cuts out, reverses the balances and translates the print into his own syntax.
A single direct copy of Rembrandt, in the middle of a vast paper museum
What Van Gogh copies in Saint-Rémy
Deprived of travel and regular models, he worked from reproductions by Millet, Delacroix, Doré and Rembrandt. Copying becomes a way to stay in dialogue with art history, find rhythm and test colorful harmonies.
What not to say
There is not a series of numerous paintings "after Rembrandt" comparable to his variations after Millet. There Resurrection of Lazarus is the direct case, documented and preserved. The other links relate above all to admiration, visual memory and convergences of method.
In Van Gogh, copying means translating: preserving ancient architecture while changing framing, color, material and emotional temperature.
Potato Eaters: a Rembranesque Light?
The painting precedes the decisive visit to the Rijksmuseum by a few months, but Van Gogh already knows Rembrandt through museums, books and prints. A unique lamp organizes the room, isolates faces and brings hands out of an environment brown green. The comparison with Dutch chiaroscuro is therefore legitimate, provided that the work is not reduced to an imitation.
Van Gogh pursues his own objective: to show that these peasants earned their meal by working the land with the same hands that take the potatoes. The deliberately harsh proportions, the protruding fronts and the palette earth color seeks social truth. Rembrandt offers a memory of light and gravity; Millet, model studies and rural life in Nuenen provide immediate grounding.
The difference is revealing. In Rembrandt, chiaroscuro can open up a spiritual or narrative space. In Van Gogh, in 1885, the domestic lamp made an economy of poverty, fatigue and sharing noticeable.
Peasants, old people and readers: the dignity of ordinary lives
Van Gogh admired in Rembrandt what he called, in 1889, a tenderness of looks. He cites them Pilgrims of Emmaus, The Jewish Bride and several portraits. This tenderness is not decorative sweetness: it comes from the ability to make one feel an interior life with few signs. Van Gogh applies it to the inhabitants of Nuenen, the old, the sick and the workers. Anatomies sometimes remain angular; dignity arises precisely from the refusal to idealize.
The face as proof of painting
Both Rembrandt and Van Gogh have multiplied self-portraits, but the analogy must remain measured. Rembrandt used his face for four decades: expression study, trony, status image, technical demonstration and portrait of painter. Van Gogh represents himself mainly for lack of a model, to quickly experiment and build his identity as an artist.
In theSelf-portrait with gray felt hat from 1887, colored features radiate around the face. The shadow is no longer brown: it breaks down into blues, greens, oranges and reds. Rembrandt showed him that a face could remain alive in visible matter; impressionism and Neo-Impressionism gave him the chromatic means to reformulate this lesson.
L'Self-portrait with easel de Rembrandt, dated 1660, offers counterpoint: the dark and massive body, the instruments and the gaze construct the authority of the aging painter. Van Gogh does not take up the costume or the pose. Rather, he shares the idea that the artist's face can be a public laboratory.
What goes from Rembrandt to Van Gogh - and what changes
| Question | Rembrandt | Van Gogh | Nature of the link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Light | Chiaroscuro, localized foci, reserve of support in the print | Color contrasts, lamps, suns and halos of touches | Transformed heritage, never identical recipe |
| Matter | Impasto, glaze, scratches, hierarchical finishes | Directional touch, visible paste, rhythmic contours | Common belief that the invoice carries meaning |
| Faces | Ages, expressions, views and historical roles | Peasants, workers, relatives and self-portraits | Dignity of non-idealized people |
| Copy | Variation and emulation of old masters | Translation of reproductions into modern color | Historical practice reinvented |
| Spirituality | The biblical made human by light and gesture | The sacred moved towards nature, sun and compassion | Interpretive parentage, non-doctrinal identity |
What the documents actually allow us to say
Established facts
- Van Gogh often mentions Rembrandt in his correspondence.
- He visited the Rijksmuseum in October 1885 and commented The Trustees and The Jewish Bride.
- In May 1890 he painted a Resurrection of Lazarus based on a rotogravure of Rembrandt etching.
- He reframes the scene, removes Christ and introduces a colorful palette.
Readings to be presented with caution
- Lazarus' sun may evoke Christ, but Van Gogh does not explicitly identify it.
- The resemblance between Lazarus and Vincent does not prove a hidden self-portrait.
- The light of Potato eaters recalls Rembrandt without deriving from one painting unique.
- The story of the "ten years of life" comes from the late memory of Kerssemakers.
How to observe influence without looking for photographic resemblance
Frame
Compare what Van Gogh keeps and takes away from Lazarus' scene.
Follow the light
Locate its source: ray, lamp, white reserve, sun or chromatic contrast.
Look at the hands
Among the two painters, they often tell stories even before faces.
Measure the finish
Identify specific areas and those deliberately left freer.
Separate the evidence
A letter or copy documents a link; a simple resemblance remains a hypothesis.
A journey between Amsterdam, Paris and print collections
Van Gogh Museum
The Resurrection of Lazarus, Potato Eaters and many self-portraits; check the hanging before the visit.
Rijksmuseum
The Jewish Bride and The Trustees are normally presented in the Gallery of Honor.
Louvre Museum
The Pilgrims of Emmaus from 1648 allow us to understand the "tenderness" described by Van Gogh.
Printing cabinets
The Metropolitan Museum, the Rijksmuseum and the British Museum preserve records of Rembrandt's engravings.
Works on paper are sensitive to light and rarely permanently exhibited. Check museum pages before traveling.
Compare Rembrandt's material and Van Gogh's color
The store offers the three central works of this story: the transposition of Lazarus by Van Gogh, The Jewish Bride from Rembrandt and Potato Eaters. They allow you to choose between solar biblical scene, late intimacy and peasant chiaroscuro without confusing documented copy and simple influence.
FAQ: Van Gogh facing Rembrandt
Did Van Gogh really admire Rembrandt?
Yes. His letters quote him regularly and accurately describe his admiration for the hands, looks, touch and poetry of several works.
Did Van Gogh meet Rembrandt?
No. Rembrandt died in 1669, almost two centuries before Van Gogh's birth in 1853.
How many works by Rembrandt Van Gogh did he copy?
One painting direct is solidly documented: The Resurrection of Lazarus from 1890, based on a rotogravure of Rembrandt's etching.
Is the Resurrection of Lazarus a faithful copy?
No. Van Gogh reframes strongly, suppresses Christ and the crowd, then translates black and white into intense colors.
Why did The Jewish Bride impact him so much?
There he admired intimacy, the material of clothing, living hands and Rembrandt's ability to overcome simple resemblance.
Are Potato Eaters inspired by Rembrandt?
Dutch chiaroscuro is part of their horizon, but the painting also results from Nuenen's peasant studies and Van Gogh's admiration for Millet.
Did Van Gogh copy an original at the museum?
For Lazare, no: he worked in Saint-Rémy according to one reproduction etching print.
Did Rembrandt influence Van Gogh's colors?
Indirectly. Rembrandt teaches him the expressive power of matter and light; Delacroix, the Impressionists and Japan play a more direct role in his lively palette.
Why are their self-portraits often compared?
Both artists use their faces as an available model and technical laboratory, but their goals, periods, and pictorial languages differ.
Where to see the main works?
At the Van Gogh Museum and the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam, at the Louvre in Paris and in the print cabinets of the Metropolitan Museum, the Rijksmuseum and the British Museum.
Correspondence and museum references
- Vincent van Gogh, letter 535 to Theo, circa October 13, 1885
- Vincent van Gogh, letter 784 to Theo, July 2, 1889
- Van Gogh Letters - scientific note on the heliogravure of Lazarus
- Rijksmuseum - Isaac and Rebecca, known as The Jewish Bride
- Rijksmuseum - Van Gogh and the museum collection
- Metropolitan Museum - Rembrandt, The Raising of Lazarus: The Larger Plate
- Van Gogh Museum - The Raising of Lazarus (after Rembrandt)
Iconographic interpretations are separated from inventory data. Attributions and hangings may change.
0 comments